But that DNA also matched samples from a number of cases between 1981 to 1986 left by a suspect who became known as the Pillowcase Rapist, Miami-Dade State Attorney Katherine Fernandez Rundle said in a news conference.
The assailant in those cases is believed to have attacked more than 40 women in metropolitan Miami, often concealing his face with a pillowcase, shirt or towel.
In all, authorities have linked Koehler to at least 25 cases, Fernandez Rundle said.
Investigators searched Koehler’s home, underneath which they found an excavated area where they believe Koehler was building “a dungeon,” Miami-Dade County Prosecutor Laura Adams said.
“We feared very much that if we had not gotten him into custody that he may have had other plans even worse than what he executed on all of these women from these cases,” Adams said.
Several safes were found, one of which contained jewelry and trinkets authorities believe could be souvenirs from his victims, Adams said. They also located a metal nail file wrapped in protective covering that Adams said could have been used as a weapon in many of the Pillowcase Rapist cases.
Police believed for years that the same man was responsible for each of the attacks based on DNA samples, Fernandez Rundle said Thursday. But they didn’t know who it was.
The “key breakthrough” came when Koehler’s son was recently arrested in an unrelated domestic violence case, Fernandez Rundle said. His DNA was similar enough to the Pillowcase Rapist’s that investigators believed the unknown assailant was his father.
After his arrest, police obtained a search warrant allowing them to get a swab of Koehler’s DNA to confirm the match, Fernandez Rundle said Thursday.
So far, Koehler faces two two felony counts of armed sexual battery in the 1983 case. He pleaded not guilty in an initial court appearance Tuesday in Brevard County. He was then moved to Miami-Dade County, where a judge ordered him held without bond in a hearing Friday.
A prosecutor in that hearing argued he should be held because “his DNA has been linked to numerous other sex offenses.”
CNN has reached out to the public defender’s office for comment.
CNN’s Jamiel Lynch, Jason Hanna, Kevin Conlon and Rosa Flores contributed to this report.